Cognitive Distortion #1: All-or-Nothing Thinking (Post #37)

Cognitive Distortion #1: All-or-Nothing Thinking (Post #37)

Cognitive Distortion #1: All-or-Nothing Thinking

Have you ever told yourself, “If I can’t do it perfectly, I’m not doing it at all”?
Or maybe, “If I mess up once, I’ve failed completely”?

That’s what we call All-or-Nothing Thinking — seeing people or situations in extremes, like success or failure, perfect or worthless, good or bad. There’s no middle ground.

This distortion is one of the most dangerous because it stops progress before it even starts.

 

The Trap of Perfection

All-or-Nothing Thinking sounds like this:

  • “I’ll never be good at that, so why even try?”
  • “If I can’t lose 20 pounds this month, I’m a failure.”
  • “If I make one mistake, everything is ruined.”

Here’s the danger — that kind of thinking doesn’t just create stress; it destroys confidence. It convinces you that anything less than perfect isn’t worth doing.

Let’s put it into perspective with a simple example:

Imagine you’re building a doghouse for your new puppy.
You build the foundation — perfect.
The walls — perfect.
Then you finish the roof… and notice it’s slightly crooked.

What happens next?
Do you fix it and finish?
Or do you get frustrated, tear it apart, and give up completely?

Many of us, when trapped in All-or-Nothing Thinking, kick our hard work to pieces over one small imperfection — forgetting that 95% of what we did was right.

 

Why It’s So Destructive

This thinking pattern erases your progress.
Instead of celebrating what’s right, you obsess over what’s wrong.
Instead of fixing what’s minor, you restart everything — emotionally, mentally, or even physically.

And the worst part? You end up increasing your workload and your stress.
Now, you’re not just rebuilding the doghouse — you’re also cleaning up the mess you made when you destroyed it.

Sound familiar?
How many times have we done this with our goals, relationships, or even self-image?

 

The Shift: Progress Over Perfection

Here’s the truth: You don’t need to be perfect. You need to keep going.

When something doesn’t turn out right, remind yourself:

  • You’ve already made progress.
  • You’re learning something valuable.
  • Mistakes are part of growth.

Fix the roof — don’t burn down the house.

Start celebrating your wins, no matter how small. When you do, you train your mind to see progress instead of failure. And that mindset builds resilience, confidence, and peace.

Because life isn’t black or white — it’s all the beautiful shades in between.

You are Confident. Resilient. Beautiful.

 

Reflection Prompt

What’s one area of your life where you’ve been too “all or nothing”?
What’s one thing you can start celebrating today, even if it’s not perfect?


Leave a comment

Please note, comments must be approved before they are published

This site is protected by hCaptcha and the hCaptcha Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.


You may also like

View all
Example blog post
Example blog post
Example blog post